Crumbl Cookies Tracker

Cookies of the week (March 1, 2021 through March 6, 2021)

Chocolate Cupcake

A warm sugar cookie topped with fudge frosting and chocolate sprinkles

Lemon Glaze

A warm lemon sugar cookie topped with lemon glaze and a slice of lemon

Reese's Pieces

A warm peanut butter cookie with Reeses pieces candies

Birthday Cake featuring OREO

A warm OREO cookie rolled in OREO crumbs, topped with birthday cake frosting, OREO cake balls and rainbow sprinkles

Cookies of the week (February 22, 2021 through February 27, 2021)

Cinnamon Swirl

A warm vanilla sugar cookie topped with cinnamon sugar and cream cheese frosting

Caramel Popcorn

A warm buttery cookie with a fluffy caramel frosting and a thick caramel drizzle topped with caramel popcorn

Peanut Butter Bar

Warm peanut butter oatmeal cookie topped with chocolate fudge frosting

Molten Lava

A warm dark chocolate cookie with a gooey fudge center dusted with powdered sugar

Cookies of the week (February 15, 2021 through February 20, 2021)

Pink Velvet

A warm cake batter cookie topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and pink velvet cookie crumbs

Strawberry Poptart

A warm buttery cookie stuffed with strawberry filling topped with white chocolate and sprinkles


A warm vanilla sugar cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar

Reese's Cup - a Tony Botros favorite

Reese's Cup®

A warm peanut butter cookie topped with melted milk chocolate, peanut butter and Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups

Cookies of the week (February 8, 2021 through February 13, 2021)

Birthday Cake

A warm cake batter cookie topped with cake batter cream cheese frosting and sprinkles

Red Velvet White Chip

A warm red velvet cookie with white chocolate chips

Nutella® Sea Salt

A warm Nutella®-stuffed cookie topped with a Nutella® drizzle and a sprinkle of sea salt

Dirt Cake

A warm Oreo® cookie rolled in Oreo® crumbs topped with chocolate frosting, chocolate streusel, more Oreo® crumbs and a gummy lip

Cookies of the week (February 1, 2021 through February 6, 2021)


A warm cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar topped with cinnamon buttercream and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar

Circus Animal - a Tony Botros Favorite

Circus Animal

A warm sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles topped with white chocolate, more sprinkles, and a mini circus animal cookie


A warm peanut butter cookie with Butterfinger® pieces topped with a milk chocolate drizzle and crushed Butterfinger

Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake

A chilled dark chocolate cookie with rich strawberry cheesecake filling topped with a drizzle of semi sweet chocolate

1/31/21 - This week has 3 repeats: the Churro, Circus Animal, and the Butterfinger. Of those 3, I have only tried the Butterfinger and it very much tasted just like candy bar. The cookie was a little dry so I paired the cookie with vanilla ice cream and that brought the cookie experience from an 8/10 to a 9/10. I have not tried the Churro or the Circus Animal cookies but word on the street is that both cookies are very good.

This is the first time I've ever seen the Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake cookie on the menu. It looks fantastic. When I visit Crumbl Cookies this week I will definitely try this cookie and may add on the Churro or the Circus Animal if I'm feeling lucky...or hungry.

2/6/21 - I tried the Circus Animal and it was da bombbbb! If you are into that traditional sugar cookie then this is the cookie for you. It basically tasted like a birthday cake sugar cookie. The churro was okay - really a large dose of cinnamon. The chocolate strawberry cheesecake was a huge disappointment. The strawberry tasted extremely artificial and there was cheesecake to be found when tasting this cookie. The only thing decent about the cookie was the dark chocolate cookie...but other than that it was gross.

Cookies of the week (January 25, 2021 through January 30, 2021)

Buckeye Brownie

A warm chocolate cookie with semi-sweet chips topped with peanut butter mousse and a semi-sweet chocolate drizzle

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

A warm oatmeal cookie with milk chocolate chips

Chilled Cookies & Cream Milkshake

A chilled cookies & cream cookie topped with cookies & cream frosting and a mini Oreo


A warm cornbread cookie topped with a honey butter glaze and a dollop of honey buttercream

Cookies of the week (January 18, 2021 through January 23, 2021)

Biscoff® Lava

A warm Biscoff®-stuffed cookie topped with a Biscoff® drizzle and Biscoff® cookie crumbs

Snickerdoodle Cupcake

A warm vanilla sugar cookie topped with cream cheese frosting and dusted with cinnamon sugar

Frozen Hot Chocolate - a Tony Botros favorite

Frozen Hot Chocolate

A chilled cocoa cookie topped with a hot chocolate mousse, mini marshmallows and powdered sugar

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip

A warm pumpkin spice cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips

This is the 2nd time I've seen Biscoff Lava. The last time I saw it was late November 2020. Very good cookie. This is the first time I've seen the other 3 cookies though. Crumbl did have a hot chocolate cookie around Christmas time but it was not "frozen."

Update: I came in for the cookies this week and tried the frozen hot chocolate and it was super good. The chocolate mousse definitely gave it a nice sweetness and texture. I may go again this week to get it one more time. I also got the Biscoff Lava and, as mentioned, it tastes great. The cookie has a melty Biscoff filling in the cookie which takes the cookie to the next level. Check out the video below to see the cookie experience for this week.

Cookies of the week (January 11, 2021 through January 16, 2021)

Carrot Cake

A warm carrot cake cookie topped with rich cream cheese frosting

Lemon Poppy Seed

A warm lemon poppy seed sugar cookie with lemon citron filling topped with a lemon almond glaze

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

A warm peanut butter cookie with milk chocolate chips

Chocolate Cake

A warm chocolate cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips topped with chocolate fudge frosting

Cookies of the week (January 4, 2021 through January 9, 2021)

Hazlenut Churro

A warm cinnamon cookie stuffed with Nutella and rolled in cinnamon sugar

Classic Peanut Butter

A warm peanut butter cookie with the classic fork-hatch pattern

Confetti Cake

A warm confetti sugar cookie topped with pink vanilla cream cheese frosting and confetti sprinkles

Chilled Twix - a Tony Botros Favorite

Chilled Twix

A chilled sugar cookie topped with thick caramel and milk chocolate